Home
Surname List
Name Index
Sources
Email Us

Fifth Generation


442. Lt. Joseph LEONARD465 was born on 29 Jul 1732 in Middleboro, Plymouth Co., MA.466 He died in 1786 in Middleboro, Plymouth Co., MA.467 ECL: "He was a Lieutenant in the Militia."

Referred to as Joseph Leonard 3rd in marriage by Benjamin Ruggles. Also,apparently, in Bodge's soldiers who served in the Revolutionary War.Bodge lists at least 3 Joseph Leonards of Middleboro serving in theRevolution. Joseph Leonard 3rd was a private in the 3rd Co. ofMinuteman, Capt. Amos Wade commanding. Joseph Leonard 5th was also aprivate in the same 3rd Co. (as did Moses Leonard and Michael Leonard).He was probably Joseph Leonard 3rd's son. They apparently served a shorttime around Boston and marched to Marshfield at the time of the Lexingtonalarm. There was also a Joseph Leonard, pvt., in the 3rd Co. of Infantryunder Capt. William Tupper. This company also had a Joseph Leonard,corporal, a Benjamin Leonard, sergeant, and privates Archippus, Perez,George, Samuel, Rowland, and Ichabod Leonard as well as Jesse Bryant(father of Nathaniel Leonard's wife Betsey Bryant). This company wasmobilized when a British fleet of 16 vessels appeared off Newport, butwas dismissed when the fleet disappeared.

ECL/GML notes refer to Massachusetts Vital Records as source of birthdate for Joseph and Joseph and Abigail's marriage date. They note analternative marriage date of October 11, 1753, per Boston Transcript.

His eldest son, Joseph, was appointed to administer his estate. He diedin early 1786. "Court of Common Pleas - April 1785 - The followingpersons were empowered, upon their petitions, to sell theirdecedents'real estate for payment of debts and charges as listed. Each was orderedto post notification 30 days before the sale and to account with thejudge of probate for the proceeds: 7. Joseph Leonard IV, adm. JosephLeonard, Gent. (Middleborough): £137.11s. *Additional Information fromAppellate Records, May 1786." Joseph Leonard IV had previously beenJoseph Leonard V, but since Joseph Leonard I died in 1775, he had movedup a notch.

Many of Joseph's relatives, direct and by marriage, were members of theFirst Church of Middleborough. These would include his grandmother,Charity Leonard, his maternal grandparents Nathaniel Southworth and JaelBennet, his wife's father, grandfather, and great-grandfather (BarnabusRaymond, John Jr., and John Sr.), his son Nathaniel's wife, Betsy Bryant,her parents, Jesse Bryant and Mercy Shaw, grandparents Jesse Bryant andSusannah Winslow, and great-grandparents Conant. See The First Church ofMiddleborough, 1854, which lists its membership through 1854, repeated inan appendix of Thomas Weston's HIstory of Middleborough, 1905.

Many of Joseph's children have the same names as those of Joseph'sfather, Joseph, but there's little or no information about them. The GMLcharts list Joseph, Noah, Gideon, Hannah, Timothy, Abiah, Nathaniel,Fear, Abigail, and Remember.

In the Genealogical Register of Plymouth Families, under BenjaminSouthworth, the following:

"Nathaniel, son of first Constant, m. 1672, Desire, d. of Edward Gray,and had Constant, 1674, Mary, 1676, m. Joseph Rider; Ichabod, 1678;Elizabeth, m. James Sproat; Nathaniel, 1684, m. Jael Howland; Edward,1688, m. Bridget Bosworth. Nathaniel, Middleboro', son of above, hadFear, 1709, married a Leonard; Gideon, Nathaniel, Samuel, and Hannah, m.a Sproat." Fear Southworth married Joseph Leonard, the father of JosephLeonard, Jr. Joseph Leonard, Sr. did not have a son Samuel, but did havea Gideon, Nathaniel, and Hannah (who married Robert Sproat) among hischildren." This is an incomplete list of Joseph's children and ispartially wrong (no Samuel). Also, this may be the origin of informationthat Jael Bennet was a Howland (she was a Bennet).

The Problem of Multiple Joseph Leonards in Middleborough in the late1700's:

Quote from the Boston Transcript, January 27, 1919, piece by W.W.N.Y.#7174 published March 24, 1919: "The Leonard family of Middleboro hasnever been written up. It is an almost inextricable mixture of thedescendants of James (1) Leonard of Taunton. The descendants of Solomon(1) Bridgewater are already published. The descendants of James (1) ofTaunton are available in the very incomplete chart of Mrs. Koster, butthe Middleboro line is almost entirely omitted. I have secured allLeonards in Middleboro records up to 1800. As soon as I have themstraightened out in families, I will send them to the Transcript, so thatthey may be available to others who are interested in the Leonardfamily.

"First, however, I am anxious to straighten out the five Joseph Leonardswho appear and I shall be grateful for any help or suggestions.

"First, we have the birh of Joseph, April 9, 1705, son of Elkanah. Thisis surely Joseph (4), Elkanah (3), Thomas 2, James 1). He was born April9, 1705, married first, April 9, 1729, Hannah (4) Pratt (Samuel 3, 2,Phineas1), second, November 18, 1731 Fear (4) Southworth (Nathaniel 3, 2,Constant 1). By the first wife there were evidently no children. Thechildren of Joseph and Fear were: Joseph (5), born July 29, 1732;Timothy, born April 19, 1734; Hannah, born July 3, 1736; Abiah, born May8, 1728, and Gideon, born October 15, 1739.

"The next Joseph is known as Joseph Leonard, Jr., who was married March27, 1746 to Ruth (4) White (Benjamin 3, Ebenezer 2, Thomas 1). He surelywas not a son of the preceding Joseph, and of course the terms senior andjunior in those days referred more frequently to age than to familyrelationship. I have no knowledge of the parentage of Joseph, Jr. Thechildren of Joseph and Ruth were as follows: Hannah, born October 8,1746, died December 5, 1751, Benajah, born October 2, 1748, died Dec. 8,1751; Joseph, born September 14, 1752; Ruth, born Aug. 28, 1754; Betty,born July 22, 1756; Archippus, born December 4, 1758; Rowland, born April24, 1761; Ichabod, born March 28, 1762; Benajah, born July 21, 1765, andHannah, born Aug. 6, 1767. These names offer little clue, although thefact that Hannah and Benajah were used before the names of the parentsand then were repeated later when both children died shows that they wereused in honor of some revered person. Elkanah (3) Leonard had an eldestson Elkanah (4), born Dec. 15, 1703, who married at Taunton Oct. 21,1725, Elizabeth Tisdale. He came to Middleboro with his parents. Hisfirst child born there was Elkanah (5), born December 30, 1727. I havewondered if a son Joseph (5) might not have been born before that,perhaps at Taunton about September, 1726, who would have been the Joseph,Jr., of Middleboro who married in 1746 Ruth White. It was a very commonthing for uncle and nephew of the same name to be called senior andjunior. This is, however, pure guess work to account for a mystery. Iam especially anxious to know who Joseph Leonard, Jr., was who marriedRuth White in 1746 and shall be grateful for any clue. Joseph (3)Leonard (Isaac 2, Solomon 1), born about 1675, Joseph (3) Leonard(Benjamin 2, James 1), born Jan. 22, 1692, and Joseph (3) (Joseph 2,James 1) are unaccounted for and may have been grandfathers of a Joseph.

"Next comes Joseph Leonard, who married, May 7, 1752, Abigail 5 Raymond(Barnabas, John 3, 2, 1). I have no record of his children. He wasquite surely Joseph (5) (Joseph 4, Elkanah 3, Thomas 2, James 1), born asabove stated July 29, 1732. He died October 11, 1793, aged sixty-three.(Note: wrong death date for this Joseph -- he died abt. 1786.)

"Then we have two children recorded as children of Joseph (Second) andRuth: Abigail, born March 2, 1770, and James, born May 13, 1772. Whowas Joseph, Second? I suspect that he was the same Joseph, Jr., above,who married Ruth White, and particularly as these two children fit on theend of his family as given above.

"Next we have another, Joseph Leonard, Jr., who married, November 20,1777, Rebecca (5) Lyon (Jedidiah 4, Samuel 3, William2). He wasevidently the Joseph above mentioned, born September 14, 1752, son ofJoseph and Ruth (White) Leonard. The children of Joseph and Rebeccawere: Ruth, born June 3, 1778, Isaac, born November 24, 1779, Molly,born Oct. 15, 1781; Druid, born April 5, 1784; Lucy, born June 24, 1786;Rebecca, born May 30, 1788, died Dec. 22, 1791; Rebecca, born Nov. 18,1791, and Hannah, born May 23, 1794.

"Finally we have the marriage of Joseph Leonard, December 3, 1778, toElizabeth (6) Richmond (Joseph 5, 4, 3, John 2, 1). The Richmondgenealogy calls him Joseph (3) Leonard, but the Middleboro records sayJoseph (4). The Richmond book states that they moved away to New YorkState after having two children, Joseph and Betsey. Betsey marriedNovember 7, 1801, Andrew Leonard, born March 3, 1774, son of Benjamin andHannah (Pratt) Leonard. (W.W.N.Y. has the ancestry of this Josephwrong. It was Joseph6, 5, 4, Elkanah3, Thomas2, James1.)

"According to the above, I have placed Joseph Leonard, Sr., and JosephLeonard, Third. Will someone help with Joseph Leonard, Jr., JosephLeonard, Second, and Joseph Leonard, Fourth? As soon as these areplaced, I will gladly contribute all the Middleboro Leonard that I havecollected." W.W.N.Y.

Unfortunately, the confusion did not end with W.W.N.Y. Nor did he doanother column to undo the confusion.

The six Josephs living in Middleborough in the late 1700's are:

- Joseph 1 1705-1775 m. 1731 Fear Southworth (Elkanah 3, Thomas2, James 1)
- Joseph 2nd or Jr. 1718-1813 m. 1746 Ruth White (Joseph 3,Benjamin 2, James 1)
- Joseph 3rd 1732-1786 m. 1752 Abigail Raymond (Joseph 4, Elkanah3, Thomas 2, James 1) (Son of Joseph and Fear)
- Joseph 4th Sep 1752-? Maine m. Rebecca Lyon (Joseph4, 3, Benjamin2, James 1) (Son of Joseph and Ruth)
- Joseph 5th 1752-1844 m. 1777 Elizabeth Richmond (Joseph 5, 4,Elkanah 3, Thomas 2, James 1) (Son of Joseph and Abigail)
- Joseph th? 1730-1793 m. 1750 Huldah Dean (Joseph 4, 3, Jacob 2,Solomon 1) (He was 63 when he died) (Solomon Leonard line)

The presumption is that living Josephs of the same family were givensuffixes in order of their births.

There are several problems that come up frequently. It would appear thatthe Joseph Leonard who married Ruth White was the son of Joseph(3)Leonard, son of Benjamin 2, James 1. There is a question as to who thewife of Joseph 3 in this line was. Hannah Jennings appears to be wrong-- she married a Joseph(3) Leonard (John2, Solomon1) of the SolomonLeonard line in Bridgewater. But if not Hannah Jennings, who was hiswife? Also, if Ruth White was as WWNY has it -- dau. of Benjamin White-- then she was born in Weymouth, MA, 25 September 1715, dau. of BenjaminWhite and Ruth Reed. Ruth Reed died 5 May 1724, so she couldn't havegiven birth to a dau. Ruth in 1725. So it probably was a different RuthWhite who m. Joseph3 in this line.

OneWorldTree has numerous entries placing the wrong Joseph Leonard inthis line, usually the one who married Ruth White (although this may havechanged recently). ECL is quite definite about the parentage, marriage,and children of this Joseph Leonard. If Joseph Leonard b. 1732 was theone who m. Ruth White in 1746, he would have been only 14 at the time,rather unlikely. These presumably come from the Mayflower Society'slisting the Joseph Leonard who married Ruth White in one of their SilverBooks. Paul Bumpus at the Mayflower Society found Joseph listed as#68563 in the James Chilton line, but the Mayflower Society had earliermismatched Joseph's wife as Ruth White rather than Abigail Raymond, whichmay now have been corrected.

There was another Joseph (5) Leonard (Joseph 4, 3, Jacob 2, Solomon 1) ofthe Solomon Leonard line also in Middleborough. His children BetsyBriggs and Lucy Leonard sold his homestead in Middleborough to JonathanLeonard of Middleborough on May 6, 1796 after he died. His son Joseph inUnion, NY, signed off on the sale. Land was sold to support his widow.This establishes his death date among the Josephs. It was a differentJoseph Leonard than the Joseph who married Abigail -- those aren't hisdaughters as listed by ECL. I don't a Betsy Leonard Briggs in this database. I don't have any Betsy Leonards that fit. What I find that fitsis that a Joseph Leonard of the Solomon Leonard line, wife Huldah Dean,married 31 January 1750 in Raynham, died in Bridgewater 11 October 1793.He had daughters Betsey and Lucy, as well as a son, Joseph, who was born2 June 1754 in Middleboro and died 1 Dec 1842 in Binghamton, NY. Otherchildren included Huldah Leonard, Mary, Silas, and Jonathan. Betsey alsodied in NY.

The 1790 Census lists four Joseph Leonards living in Middleborough, plusAbigail, wife of the Joseph who died in 1788. Abigail is listed ashaving 5 females in the household. Nearby is Joseph Leonard (the one whomarried Elizabeth Richmond?), with 2 males 16+ and 3 females, who mayhave been her son, Joseph. Also listed nearby are Noah (another son),Zebulon, and Elkanah. Another Joseph Leonard's household had 1 male 16+,2 under 16, and 6 females, listed next to Jesse Bryant's household andPhilip Leonard (3 males 16+, 1 male under 16, and 4 females. The Josephwho married Ruth White had a brother Philip and 10 children. AnotherJoseph Leonard had a household of 7, 2 males 16+, 1 male under 16, and 3females. The Joseph who married Rebecca Lyon had 8 children, 6 female ofwhich 4 were born before 1791. There was another Joseph Leonardhousehold with 2 males 16+ and 1 female. Other Leonards listed in the1790 Census in Middleborough include Jonathan (household of 5), Micah(household of 9), Perez (household of 5) listed next to Zadock (householdof 10), Henry (household of 5), listed near Benjamin (household of 14),Ephraim (household of 3), and Henry (household of 2), Samuel Leonard(household of 3), Archippus Leonard (household of 4 -- listed near Josephand Philip) George Leonard (household of 7).

Looking through the Plymouth Court cases, Joseph Leonard appears withreasonable frequency, but it's hard to tell which was which from anidentification as "Joseph Leonard, Gent., Middleborough." A JosephLeonard was a grand juror in 1713-14. Joseph Leonard was a Tauntonbloomer in a case in the 1724-28 time frame. Joseph Leonard, refiner ofiron, Middleborough, was involved in a couple of cases in 1769. JosephLeonard, Senior, gent., Middleborough, was involved in a case 28 Mar 1772over $30. Joseph Leonard III was in court over a note in 1781. JosephLeonard was mentioned as a sheriff between October 1782 and October1785. Joseph Leonard IV was empowered by the Court to sell property tosettle debts of 137 pounds of Joseph Leonard, Gent., of Middleborough in1783-85. Joseph Leonard, yeoman, Middleborough, attached Elijah Reed,yeoman, Middleborough, in 1783. Joseph Leonard III had a deed of saleapproved by the Court in 1784. Joseph Leonard II was a Middleboromillwright in a case 8 Sep 1797. Joseph Leonard II, yeoman,Middleborough, and Leonard Sears, yeoman, Middleborough, were in court in1797. (Leonard Sears was married to a daughter of Joseph III, AbiahLeonard). It will take a bit of doing to straighten out which Joseph waswhich, particularly since the designations, I, II, III, and IV changed asJosephs died or moved away.

It appears that a "yeoman" had to own some amount of land to justify thetitle; a farmer working on leased land was a "husbandman;" a man workingfor a wage such as a forgeman or bloomer was titled exactly that, andit's unclear what a "gentleman" was (a profession not requiring manuallabor or working for a wage?).

It's easy to understand why the Josephs are easy to confuse, withmismatches of wives and children also occurring. I hope ECL/GML and Ihave it right in this Leonard genealogy, but "don't take anything forgranted!"

Perhaps the names Noah and Remember, which don't occur in this line ofthe Leonard family, were picked up from the Raymond side....

Benjamin Leonard of Solomon line bought 100 acres of land in Ashford, CT,of Joseph Leonard of Middleborough, deed dated 16 May 1771. Which Joseph?

Lt. Joseph LEONARD and Abigail RAYMOND were married on 7 May 1752 in Middleborough, Plymouth, MA.66 Abigail RAYMOND468 (daughter of Barnabus RAYMOND and Alice BENT) was born on 3 Oct 1732 in Middleboro, Plymouth Co., MA.2 She died on 15 Jul 1810 in Middleboro, Plymouth Co., MA. Received quarter acre of homestead farm of Benjamin Reed, 1790. She wasthe widow of Ens. Joseph Leonard.

In the 1800 Census she was living alone. Death date of 1810 isuncertain, not listed in Middleboro VR's.

The Raymond Genealogy, p. 127: "Barnabas, 24, prob. son of John 10, m.Alice..., and had at Middleboro, Mass.: Deborah, b. Aug. 1, 1729 (aDeborah m. John Cushman, of Plympton, February 3, 1746). Abigail, b.October 3, 1732 (an Abigail m. Joseph Leonard, 3rd, of Middleboro, May 7,1752. ..."). Lt. Joseph LEONARD and Abigail RAYMOND had the following children:

+986

i.

Joseph LEONARD.

+987

ii.

Noah LEONARD.

+988

iii.

Gideon LEONARD.

+989

iv.

Capt. Timothy LEONARD.

+990

v.

Abiah LEONARD.

+991

vi.

Ensign Nathaniel LEONARD.

992

vii.

Fear LEONARD469 was born in 1770 in Middleborough, Plymouth, MA. She died in 1846. ECL: "She died unmarried." I can't find any other information about her.

+993

viii.

Abigail Nabby LEONARD.

+994

ix.

Remember LEONARD.

995

x.

Simeon LEONARD470 was born on 15 Jul 1779 in Middleborough, Plymouth, MA.470 He died on 12 Jun 1823 in Middleboro, Plymouth, MA.66 Not in 1790 Census for Middleborough.

A Boadicea Thompson of Bridgewater m. a Simeon Leonard 23 March 1817 inMiddleborough. Which Simeon?

This may or may not be the right birthdate; Middleborough VR's don'tidentify parents in this case.